Should You Grade Your Football Card?
This guide helps Football collectors decide whether to grade their cards based on potential ROI and market trends. Learn about key factors and examples to make informed decisions.
Grading Logic
- •High-end rookie cards from popular players should be graded to maximize value.
- •Vintage Football cards in excellent condition can significantly appreciate in value when graded.
- •Limited edition or autographed Football cards often see a strong ROI when graded.
- •Cards from championship seasons or significant games typically benefit from grading.
- •Common cards with high demand and pristine condition may be worth grading for better resale potential.
Key Characteristics
Rookie Status
Rookie cards of star players often command higher prices when graded.
Condition
The condition of the card directly impacts its grading potential and resale value.
Scarcity
Limited print runs or rare parallels can lead to increased demand for graded cards.
Historical Significance
Cards that commemorate significant moments in Football history can appreciate when graded.
When to Grade
- ✓When you have a high-value rookie card from a current star player.
- ✓If you possess vintage cards in near-mint or mint condition.
- ✓For autographed cards from significant players or events.
- ✓If the card is part of a limited edition set that is in high demand.
- ✓When your card features a historic moment in Football that enhances its appeal.
When to Skip
- ✗If the card is a common player card with little market interest.
- ✗When the card is in poor condition, which will not yield a good grade.
- ✗If the grading fees exceed the potential increase in value.
- ✗For cards that are easily obtainable and not considered collectible.
ROI Examples
| Card | Raw | PSA 9 | PSA 10 | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|---|
2020 Justin Herbert Prizm Rookie Card This card's high demand and potential for appreciation make grading worthwhile. | $100 | $400 | $1,200 | strong |
2018 Baker Mayfield Donruss Rookie Card While it has potential, the ROI is marginal considering the grading costs. | $30 | $80 | $200 | moderate |
1990 Score Joe Montana Card The low value of this common card makes grading not worth the expense. | $5 | $15 | $40 | skip |
Market Insight
The Football card market has seen a resurgence, particularly for rookie cards and limited editions. Demand for graded cards remains high, with collectors willing to pay a premium for quality, making grading a smart move for key cards.